Eea4 Surinder Singh and full time carer

[greatscott]

That case was decided by the EFTA Court who's judgments are not binding on the UK as we are a full member of the EU. It is like any other court which has to take account of CJEU case law.

I can't see how this judgment would help.

Well, yes EFTA but isn't O&B and the EFTA judgement what UK are relying on to 'overturn' Eind?

If not then what are they relying on to convince a tribunal that Eind no longer applies to a returning BC?

[WalexK]

Under SS, there is no need for you to have worked according to Eind case law. No-one on this forum, on any government web site, or anywhere in the public domain can prove that Eind law has been overturned. Therefore it still applies.

What the UK government is trying to do since 25 November 2016, is illegal.

I agree Surinder Singh 2016 regulations are illegal. But I am surprised people are taking it and the refusals. I cannot think of any other regulations been applied so sneakily in contradiction of EU law. Its not just Eind but the other conditions in Surinder Singh. Home office should stop the hypocrisy. They should imply it properly or should not apply at all.

I am surprised why there is no legal challenge to Surinder Singh regulations 2016 so far. People should crowdfund the legal challenge and should not let HO bully us which seems to be their habit these days.

Until it is done we all have to tolerate these unlawful refusals.

Well we have recently appealed and our case is the perfect case to appeal Eind, because their refusal to grant EEA(PR) is for one reason only, the "BC not being a qualified person". So crowdfund our appeal.
I happen to know a top legal advisor here in the UK.

I also happen to have the support of a top lawyer and expert in SS and freedom of movement, from The Netherlands who is happy to assist any UK lawyer/barrister with our appeal ( there will be his fee to consider). He says Eind is certainly not overturned or diminished in any way in the eyes of the EU.

Slam dunk, just need financial clout as we don't have the resources on our own.

What say you all?

Hello greatscott,
What is the outcome of the appeal? I happen to know someone that fall into such situation. I will appreciate your feed back.