Post
by ryan.spiro » Tue Apr 15, 2014 2:48 pm
First of all I'd just like to say thank you for a very good summary of the Good Character requirements.
I've sent an email to the Home Office (see detail below) outlining my case and I'd really appreciate your opinion on the subject:
My enquiry relates to a Naturalisation as a British Citizen application and specifically the Good Character requirement.
Where possible I’ve made reference to the Nationality Policy Guidance and Casework Instruction
Chapter 18, Annex D: The Good Character Requirement or Booklet AN Naturalisation Requirements (highlighted in red)
I used the Nationality Checking Service (NCS) and disclosed a 'Notice of fine and collection order' which I received from the North Surrey Magistrates' Court for the following offence - Excluded traffic on a special road - pedal cycle (Dated 20 Aug 2012). I disclosed this fine when I applied for my ILR without any issues and subsequently received my ILR.
Annex D has the following statement: ‘A non-custodial sentence or other out of court disposal that is recorded on a person’s criminal record.’ The NCS person suggested that this may apply to my offence but due to the minor nature / this is not a criminal conviction there is nothing recorded on my criminal record. As this is the case I would suggest that this offence does not fall into this category.
The Home Office guidance makes the following statement: 'We will normally disregard a single conviction for a minor offence resulting in a bind over, conditional discharge or relatively small fine or compensation order, if a person is suitable for citizenship in all other respects'. I would suggest that even if this offence requires consideration for this application, then it should fall into this category.
Annex D also has the following statement regarding exceptional grants: A non-custodial sentence which occurred within the first 2 years of the 3 (i.e. the person has had no offences within the last 12 months), there are strong countervailing factors which suggest the person is of good character in all other regards and the decision to refuse would be disproportionate. I have committed no other offences whatsoever, I’ve been completely transparent about this offence throughout the whole process, I’m a person of professional standing (Chartered Accountant) and considering the nature of the offence I would suggest that refusal on these grounds would be disproportionate.
Questions:
Is the Good Character Requirement for a British Citizenship application the same as that applied for ILR applications?
Please confirm my understanding, based on the evidence provided above, that this offence will not negatively effect the Good Character Requirement for my application?
Thanks in advance.